Curriculum Embedded Performance Task
Middle School Science
Content Standard 6.1, 6.2 or 6.4

DIG IN!
Teacher Manual
Connecticut State
Department of Education
Bureau of
Curriculum and Instruction
Acknowledgement
The Connecticut State Department of Education is grateful to the many dedicated science educators who contributed to the development of the elementary, middle and high school curriculum-embedded performance tasks and teacher manuals. Beginning with the initial ideas for tasks, through the classroom field testing and editing, to the guidelines for classroom implementation, these inquiry teaching and learning activities are the result of the creativity, experiences and insights of Connecticuts finest science educators. We thank all of you, too numerous to list, who gave your time and energy so generously to this project.
Table of Contents
Page
Overview of the Curriculum-Embedded Performance Task Model.......................................... 1
Introduction to Dig In............................................................................................................... 5
Teacher Notes......................................................................................................................... 10
Teaching Resources................................................................................................................ 17
OVERVIEW OF THE
ELEMENTARY AND MIDDLE SCHOOL
CURRICULUM-EMBEDDED
PERFORMANCE TASK MODEL
The
Connecticut State Board of Education approved the Core Science Curriculum
Framework in October of 2004. The
framework promotes a balanced approach to PK-12 science education that develops
student understanding of science content and investigative processes.
WHAT
IS A CURRICULUM-EMBEDDED PERFORMANCE TASK?
Curriculum-embedded performance tasks are examples of teaching and learning activities that engage students in using inquiry process skills to deepen their understanding of concepts described in the science framework. Developed by teachers working with the Connecticut State Department of Education, the performance tasks are intended to influence a constructivist approach to teaching and learning science throughout the school year. They will also provide a context for CMT questions assessing students ability to do scientific inquiry.
The three elementary performance tasks are conceptually related to Content Standards in Grades 3 to 5 and the three middle school performance tasks are related to Content Standards in Grades 6 to 8. The elementary performance tasks provide opportunities for students to use the Inquiry Expected Performances for Grades 3 to 5 (see Science Framework B.INQ 1-10 skills) to understand science concepts. The middle school performance tasks provide opportunities for students to use the Inquiry Expected Performances for Grades 6 to 8 (see Science Framework C.INQ 1-10 skills) to understand science concepts.
Teachers are encouraged to use the state-developed curriculum-embedded performance tasks in conjunction with numerous other learning activities that incorporate similar inquiry process skills to deepen understanding of science concepts. Students who regularly practice and receive feedback on problem-solving and critical thinking skills will steadily gain proficiency.
HOW ARE
THE PERFORMANCE TASKS STRUCTURED?
Each performance task includes two investigations; one that provides some structure and direction for students, and a second that allows students more opportunity to operate independently. The goal is to gradually increase students independent questioning, planning and data analysis skills. The elementary performance tasks introduce students to understanding and conducting fair tests. The middle school performance tasks focus on designing investigations that test cause/effect relationships by manipulating variables.
Mathematics provides a useful language for quantifying scientific observations, displaying data and analyzing findings. Each curriculum-embedded performance task offers opportunities for students to apply mathematics processes such as measuring, weighing, averaging or graphing, to answer scientific questions.
Not all science knowledge can be derived from the performance of a hands-on task. Therefore, each curriculum-embedded task gives students opportunities to expand their understanding of concepts through reading, writing, speaking and listening components. These elements foster student collaboration, classroom discourse, and the establishment of a science learning community.
A useful structure for inquiry-based learning units follows a LEARNING CYCLE model. One such model, the 5-E Model, engages students in experiences that allow them to observe, question and make tentative explanations before formal instruction and terminology is introduced. Generally, there are five stages in an inquiry learning unit:
Engagement: stimulate students interest, curiosity and preconceptions;
Exploration:
first-hand experiences with concepts without direct
instruction;
Explanation: students explanations followed by introduction of formal terms and clarifications;
Elaboration: applying knowledge to solve a problem. Students frequently develop and complete their own well-designed investigations;
Evaluation: students and teachers reflect on change in conceptual understanding and identify ideas still under development.
The performance tasks follow the 5-E learning cycle described above. However, the teacher can decide the role the performance task will play within the larger context of the entire learning unit. Early in a learning unit, the performance task can be used for engagement and exploration; later in a learning unit, the performance task might be used as a formative assessment of specific skills.
HOW ARE PERFORMANCE TASKS
USED WITH YOUR CLASS?
Curriculum-embedded performance tasks are designed to be used as part of a learning unit related to a Framework Content Standard. For example, while teaching a unit about human body systems (Content Standard 7.2,) the teacher decides the appropriate time to incorporate the Feel The Beat performance task to investigate factors affecting pulse rate. In this way, the natural flow of the planned curriculum is not disrupted by the sudden introduction of an activity sequence unrelated to what students are studying.
The performance tasks are NOT intended to be administered as summative tests. Students are not expected to be able to complete all components of the tasks independently. Teachers play an important role in providing guidance and feedback as students work toward a greater level of independence. Performance tasks provide many opportunities for teachable moments during which teachers can provide lessons on the skills necessary for students to proceed independently.
There is no single correct
answer for any of the performance tasks.
Students conclusions, however, should be logical, or valid
interpretations of data collected in a systematic, or reliable way. Variations in students procedures,
data and conclusions provide opportunities for fruitful class discussions about
designing fair tests and controlling variables. In the scientific community, scientists present their
methods, findings and conclusions to their peers for critical review. Similarly, in the science classroom,
students critical thinking skills are developed when they participate in a
learning community in which students critique their own work and the work of
their peers.
Performance tasks should be differentiated to accommodate students learning needs and prior experiences. The main goal is to give all students opportunities to become curious, pose questions, collect and analyze data, and communicate conclusions. For different learners, these same actions will require different levels of scaffolding as they move toward greater levels of independence. For example, if students have had experiences creating their own data tables, the teacher may decide to delete part or all of the data table included in the performance task. Other possible adjustments include (but are not limited to):
Text readability;
Allowing students to control all or some of the variables;
Whether the experimental procedure is provided or student-created;
Graph labels and scales provided or student-created;
Expectations for communication of results; or
Opportunities for student-initiated follow-up investigations.
There are many science investigations that are currently used in schools that provide inquiry learning opportunities similar to those illustrated in the performance tasks. Students need a variety of classroom experiences to deepen their understanding of a science concept and to become proficient in using scientific processes, analysis and communication. Teachers are encouraged to use the state-developed curriculum-embedded performance tasks in conjunction with numerous other learning activities that incorporate similar inquiry processes and critical thinking skills.
HOW ARE THE PERFORMANCE
TASKS RELATED TO THE CMT?
The new Science CMT for Grades 5 and 8 will assess students understanding of inquiry and the nature of science through questions framed within the CONTEXT of the curriculum-embedded performance tasks. Students are not expected to recall the SPECIFIC DETAILS OR THE RIGHT ANSWER to any performance task. The questions, similar to the examples shown below, will assess students general understandings of scientific observations, investigable questions, designing fair tests, making evidence-based conclusions and judging experimental quality.
Here is an example of the type of multiple-choice question that might appear on the Grade 5 Science CMT. The question is related to the Soggy Paper performance task:


Here is an example of the type of constructed-response question that might appear on the Grade 8 Science CMT. The question is related to the Feel The Beat performance task:


NOTE THAT THE CMT QUESTIONS DO
NOT ASSESS A CORRECT OUTCOME OF A PERFORMANCE TASK OR STUDENTS RECOLLECTION
OF THE DETAILS OF THE PERFORMANCE TASK.
Students who have had numerous opportunities to make observations,
design experiments, collect data and form evidence-based conclusions are likely
to be able to answer the task-related CMT questions correctly, even if they
have not done the state-developed performance tasks. However, familiarity with the context
referred to in the test question may make it easier for students to answer the
question correctly.
INTRODUCTION TO
DIG IN
In this performance task, students will explore the properties of different soils that affect how water moves through them. After preliminary observations of the composition and texture of different soils, students will conduct experiments to explore factors that affect how much water the soils can hold and how quickly water moves through them.
SAFETY NOTES:
FRAMEWORK CONTENT STANDARD(S): Dig
In can relate conceptually to any of the following learning units:
6.1 - Materials can be classified as
pure substances or mixtures, depending on their chemical and physical properties.
This is a learning unit about mixtures and
solutions. Soil is a good example
of a mixture of mineral particles, air, water, and organic material. Dig In can provide opportunities for
students to explore how the components of a mixture (i.e., soil) can be
separated using physical and chemical methods such as sieves, filters or
evaporation. The minerals and
nutrients needed by plants are dissolved in a solution of water within the
soil. Before
a nutrient can be used by plants it must be dissolved in the water that
penetrates the soil. Most minerals
and nutrients are more soluble or available in acid soils than in neutral or
slightly alkaline soils. Soil
nutrient testing is one way that solutions can be studied.
6.2
- An ecosystem is composed of all the populations that are living in
a certain space and the physical factors with which they interact.
This is a learning unit about the
interactions between living and nonliving components of an ecosystem. Dig In can provide opportunities for students
to learn about how soil conditions are affected by many variables, including
climate, topography, geology, and human activity. Soils, in turn, play a major role in determining plant
growth in an area; and the variety of plants in an ecosystem determine its
community of animals.
6.4
- Water moving across and through earth materials carries with it the
products of human activities.
This is a learning unit about how
topography and soil types affect the way in which water moves across and
through the land. Dig In can
provide opportunities for students to study how human activities such as
agriculture, land development or logging, can change soil properties by adding
pollutants or causing compaction.
Students can explore the impact of soil compaction on the way water
flows across and through the soil.
UNDERLYING SCIENCE CONCEPTS (KEY IDEAS):
KEY INQUIRY SKILLS
MATERIALS NEEDED: Listed below are all the materials needed to complete the two experiments in Dig In. Some materials are supplied in starter kits provided by the Connecticut State Department of Education. These materials are marked with an asterisk (*). The remaining materials are supplied by the school district:
For each lab group: For
each student: 4 plastic bottles (2-liter) About 1 liter each of 4 different soil types (in labeled
zip-loc bags) Scissors Piece of fine mesh (panty hose), screen, or cheesecloth Duct tape 500 mL beaker * 100 mL graduated cylinder * Water Damp sponge Stopwatch or clock
ADVANCE PREPARATION FOR THE TEACHER:
MATERIALS DISTRIBUTION:
Get students involved in distributing and
returning materials. This saves
time for the teacher and also teaches students collaborative skills and
self-reliance. One way to
distribute materials is through a cafeteria style distribution center. All materials are laid out on a table
or counter, and each group sends a representative to pick up the required
materials. Trays or plastic
shoeboxes work well for transporting materials from the center to the lab
groups.
ESTIMATED COMPLETION TIME AND PACING SUGGESTIONS:
You should reserve about a week for this activity – 5
periods or 3 blocks.
If you will teach in 40-45 minute periods:
|
Class |
Activity |
Homework |
|
1 |
Pre-lab discussion, group assignments, Experiment #1
– steps 1-2 |
Experiment #1 – steps 3-5 |
|
2 |
Groups compare individual procedures, complete
Experiment #1 – steps 6-7 |
Experiment #1 – step 8 |
|
3 |
Discuss Results & Conclusions, Experiment #1
– step 13, discuss other soil properties, introduce Experiment #2
– steps 1-2 |
Experiment #2 – steps 3-5 |
|
4 |
Groups compare individual procedures, complete
Experiment #2 – step 6-7 |
Experiment #2 – steps 8-9 |
|
5 |
Discuss Results & Conclusions, Experiment #2
– step 10 |
Communicate Your Conclusions section |
If you will teach in 80-90 minute blocks:
|
Class |
Activity |
Homework |
|
1 |
Pre-lab discussion, group assignments, Experiment #1
– steps 1-2 (this might be the second half of the block only). |
Experiment #1 – steps 3-5 |
|
2 |
Groups compare individual procedures, complete
Experiment #1 – steps 6-9, discuss other soil properties, introduce
Experiment #2 – steps 1-2 |
Experiment #2 – steps 3-5 |
|
3 |
Groups compare individual procedures, complete
Experiment #2 – step 6-10 |
Communicate Your Conclusions section |
PEDAGOGY: Consult the teacher
notes accompanying each step of the performance task for suggestions related to
classroom implementation, differentiation, assessment and extension strategies.
The symbol is used to
indicate a differentiation opportunity.
Each Teacher Note is followed by a reference to the Framework inquiry
skill featured in that task component.
For example, the notation C INQ.3 indicates an inquiry skill related to designing or conducting a simple
investigation.
Dig In!
A Guided Exploration of
How Water Moves Through Soil
ENGAGE
When you think of soil, you may think of just plain dirt. Look again at the picture of the soil
on the cover. Can you see some
things that are mixed in with the soil?
Are there other materials that are mixed in that are not so easily seen?
Teacher notes: To
peak students interest, you may distribute zip-lock bags that contain the soil
samples from the school grounds or from students homes. Compared with the soil types you may
have purchased, these samples are more likely to contain mixtures of grass,
roots, insects, pebbles, etc. Let
the students observe the soils inside the bags, and generate a class list of
the materials they can see, as well as those which may be inferred from
evidence (e.g., moisture, air, or minerals). Ask students Is soil a pure substance or a mixture? How do you know?
EXPLORE
Imagine that your class will be planting a vegetable garden as
part of a study about ecosystems. You need to choose the best location for the
garden, and one of the important factors is the type of soil.
In this activity, you will observe and compare different types of
soil. Then you will investigate
factors that may affect how much water the soils can hold and how quickly water
can pass through them. Finally,
you will apply the results of your investigations to make decisions about the
location of a new garden.
1.
Observe the different soil samples with and without the hand lens. Notice different properties such as
color, grain size, lumpiness, etc. Do you notice anything that is alive or was once alive?
Teacher notes: Cover the work space with
newspaper. Plain white paper is a
good background for observing different soil types. Encourage students to organize their observations by
labeling their samples. Show
students how to moisten their fingers and rub the soils between fingertips to detect
differences in particle size. Suggest
that students explore how well the soil holds together by making little
snakes or balls. Discuss how scientific
observations differ from facts, names, opinions or theories. C
INQ.1
2.
Record your observations in your science notebook. Make an organized list of things you
notice and things you wonder.
Teacher
notes: If your students are
experienced at using observation tables, they should be able to design their
own organized table to record the properties of the different soil types. As you circulate during this activity, you may notice that
some of your students need more structure. If this is the case, you can suggest a blank table, like
this:
|
SOIL
TYPE |
NOTICE |
WONDER |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
This is a useful strategy for helping
students turn their exploratory observations into productive questions that can
be investigated later on. C INQ.1
3. Identify
a property that may be related to the soils ability to hold water. This
property is called absorbency. Write a research question that can be
answered by doing an experiment.
Teacher notes:
Encourage them to think about what soil property might be related
to water retention. Students may theorize about properties such as the size of
the soil particles, the soil color, how compacted it is, or how much organic
material is in it. Their
experiment will allow them to test their idea. Help students to distinguish between a question that cannot
be answered through an experiment (e.g., What gives soils their color?) and a
question that can be answered through an experiment (e.g., Does soil
color affect its absorbency?).
Some questions are best answered by researching electronic or print
information, while others can be answered by collecting first-hand data. C INQ.1
Experiment #1 – Relationship Between Soil
Properties and Water Absorption
1.
For each lab group: For
each student: 2-liter plastic bottles 1 liter each of 4 different soil types (in labeled
zip-loc bags) Scissors Piece of fine mesh, panty hose, screen, or cheesecloth Duct tape 500 mL beaker 100 mL graduated cylinder Water Stopwatch or clock
Gather
the
following materials to use in planning and conducting your experiment:
2.
To conduct your experiment, you can make a soil testing
device like the one in the diagram:
a.
bottle
top
Cut the plastic bottle across the
middle. Remove the labels and the
caps. The bottle top will hold the soil, and the beaker (or the bottle bottom)
will catch the water.
b.
Position the mesh near the bottle neck so it will keep the
soil in the bottle top.
c.
Rest
the bottle top, neck down, on the bottle bottom so that water poured through
the soil in the bottle top will flow into the bottle bottom.
Teacher notes: The diagram shows one of several ways this device can
work. Depending on the materials you are using, allow students to
use their creative problem-solving skills to design their apparatus so they can
collect the data they think is important for their research. One way to keep the soil in the top
container is by wrapping the mesh around the bottle neck using duct tape. C INQ.5
3.
Design a procedure that will help you answer your research question. List the steps you will follow in your science notebook. Include enough detail so that anyone
could repeat your experiment.
Teacher notes:
Allow students ample time to talk with their lab partners about their
experimental design. They need to be
clear on their research question (e.g., Does Soil Grain Size Affect Its
Ability to Hold Water?) and how they can control all the variables to collect
reliable data related to the question. Different lab groups may explore different independent
variables, or you may structure the activity so that all lab groups explore the
effect of organic materials or soil grain size. C INQ.3
4.
In this experiment, the dependent variable is the soil absorbency. In your science notebook, record the independent
variable you will investigate and the
variables that must be kept constant in your experiment.
Teacher notes: If
your students are not experienced designing controlled experiments, you may
lead a class discussion about the dependent variable (the one thing that will
change) and the independent variable (the outcome to be measured). C
INQ.4
5.
Design a data table to record your findings in your science notebook.
Teacher notes: Remind students that the data table is useful
for recording all quantities used in the procedure. For those students who are not yet proficient at designing
their own data tables, you may want to provide them with part or all of a table
like this: C INQ.5
|
SOIL TYPE |
SOIL AMOUNT |
WATER POURED IN (in mL) |
WATER THAT CAME OUT (in mL) |
AMOUNT OF WATER LEFT IN SOIL (in mL) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
6. Do
your experiment and record your
findings. Do the data seem
reasonable? If not, do you need to
repeat any trials to correct errors?
Teacher notes: This is a good opportunity to hold a
class discussion about the need to do multiple trials in an experiment. Ask students what might be different if
they did multiple trials of the absorbency test. Students are likely to comment that the first absorbency
test was through dry soils; if they repeated the test, the soils will be
wet. Ask them if they think there
will be any difference in the results.
They may want to collect additional data to compare dry soil absorption
to wet soil absorption. Remind
them to modify their data tables to incorporate the multiple trials. C INQ.5
7. Calculate
the amount of water remaining in each
soil.
8. Teacher
notes: Now is the time to use
mathematics to process the raw scientific data. Some students may need prompting to recognize the
inverse relationship between the amount of water collected in the beaker
compared to the starting amount that was poured into the soil. When students use subtraction to compare
the ending water amount to the beginning water amount, they should be able to deduce
that the amount of water that is not in the collection beaker must be left in
the soil. If students conducted
multiple trials, guide them to recognize the need to find the average
amount of water retained by each soil in order to form a conclusion. C
INQ.6
9. Interpret
the data. Use your calculations to help you reach a conclusion about what
properties affect soil absorbency (how much water the soil holds).
Teacher notes: C
INQ.8
10. Share your
procedures and conclusions with others in your class. How are they alike?
How are they different?
What changes could be made to the procedures to make the results more
similar?
Teacher notes: Lead a post-lab discussion in which
data is displayed from lab groups who investigated the same independent
variable. This is a great
opportunity to discuss reasons for possible differences in results among lab
groups. When students share their
methods, others should comment about whether variables were properly
controlled. Good time to talk
about experimental errors that might affect student confidence in their
results. C INQ.8
EXPLAIN
Investigate Through Research
The food we eat and water we drink, in many ways, depend on the quality of the soil. Do some research in books, magazines or the Internet to find out more about what soil is, where it comes from, different soil types and how wet and dry soils affect an ecosystem.
Write a reflection in your science notebook that explains
your understanding of how the soil type affects what grows in a particular
area.
Teacher notes:
Some answers to questions come from experimental research, while others
come from reading about what is already known. Often, the information gained from the reading leads to
other questions that can be investigated experimentally. You can modify this step to reflect the
focus of your learning unit. Other
research topics include: Deforestation and Soils, Weather and Soils: The Dust
Bowl, desert soils and flash floods, soil types, mudslides and sink holes, etc.
ELABORATE
Investigating Further
Experiment #2 –
Relationship Between Soil Properties and Water Percolation Rate
In this investigation, you will
explore properties that affect how quickly water moves through different soil
types. This is called the soils percolation
rate.
1. Observe the
different soils again. What are
your ideas about soil properties that might be related to soil percolation? Discuss your ideas with your partners.
2. Predict which soil
type might have the fastest percolation rate based on the properties you
observed.
3.
Write a
procedure that will help to answer your question. To conduct your experiment, you
can use a soil testing device like the one used in Experiment #1. List
the steps you will follow in your science notebook. Include enough detail so that anyone could repeat your
experiment.
4.
Identify the dependent and independent variables in your experiment. Identify the variables that will be kept constant in your experiment.
5.
Create a data table to record your findings in your science notebook.
6. Do
your experiment and record your
findings.
7.
Think about the data you have collected. Do the data seem reasonable? If not, do you need to repeat any
trials to correct any problems?
8.
Analyze the data.
Calculate the average time it took for the water to move through each of
the soils.
9.
Interpret the
data. What conclusions can be made based on your data?
10. Share your procedures and conclusions with others in your
class. How are they alike? How are they different? What changes could be made to the
procedures to make the results more similar?
Possible Variations/Extensions
(optional):
Some plants prefer moist soil, while others prefer dry soil. You may want to find out if a soils moisture content can be changed by experimenting with different soil combinations.
Applying Your
Findings To Solve A Problem
Imagine that you are
going to plant a vegetable garden at your school or at home. You need to know what type of soil you
have so you can select the right plants and know how much or how often you will
need to water them. Use what
youve learned through your experiments and your research to describe the type
of soil in the school or home sample you have tested.
Communicate Your Conclusions:
Make a recommendation to the school principal about where the garden should be planted and how much watering it will need. Write an expository report that includes the following:
Teacher
notes: If you have elected not to
pursue the authentic garden-planning scenario, you may modify this science
writing assignment to require students to describe their observations, questions,
methods and conclusions in a variety of ways: C INQ.10
TEACHING RESOURCES
SOIL LEARNING UNITS:
http://archive.globe.gov/tctg/tgchapter.jsp?sectionId=86&rg=n&lang=en -
GLOBE (Global Learning and Observations to Benefit the Environment) is a
worldwide hands-on, primary and secondary school-based education and science
program.
http://www.fieldmuseum.org/undergroundadventure/teachers/index.shtml
http://www.urbanext.uiuc.edu/gpe/index.html - Soil and plant investigations and
information for upper elementary grades.
http://www.scienceteacher.org/k12resources/lessons/lesson15.htm - an inquiry into the effect of soil
microorganisms on the germination of grass seeds. University of Montana.
CLASSROOM
ACTIVITIES:
Washington, D.C.:
U.S. Department of Agriculture, 2001.
Available online: soils.usda.gov/sqi/files/activities.pdf
http://soils.usda.gov/sqi/files/activities.pdf
This series of three soil-related classroom activities focuses on
decomposition, earthworms, and other creatures that live in the soil.
http://www.acornnaturalists.com/store/category.asp?SID=2&Category_ID=543 – Topsoil
Tour and other soil and water investigational units.
Eco-Inquiry: A
Guide to Ecological Learning Experiences for the Elementary/Middle Grades
Kathleen Hogan
Dubuque, Ia.: Kendall/Hunt Publishing Company, 1994.
ISBN: 0840395841
The cooperative approach in this guide organizes students from ages 8-13 into
research teams to carry out investigations on food chains, decomposition, and
cycles, and then to present their findings to peers. It provides authentic
assessment tools and emphasizes group learning.
http://www.epa.gov/region01/students/pdfs/ww_well.pdf - This series of seven activities allows students to demonstrate knowledge about what ground water is, explain how it moves through the soil and how it interacts with surface water, and learn how it is extracted for use as drinking water.
Grow Your Own Garden
Learn everything you need to start your own garden.
http://www.urbanext.uiuc.edu/firstgarden/index.html